The Applicants appealed a decision of the Upper Tribunal refusing to grant permission to appeal a costs decision made in judicial review proceedings.
The Upper Tribunal refused permission to appeal by applying the second appeals test referred to in section 13(6) of the Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007.
The Applicants appealed on the error of law ground.
Sir Kenneth Parker ordered an oral permission to appeal hearing.
In relation to the point of principle, Lord Justice Peter Jackson and Lord Justice Singh held that, based on the relevant statutory provisions, in judicial review claims heard by the Upper Tribunal, rather than on appeal from the First Tier Tribunal, the test for an appeal to the Court of Appeal was the first appeal test in part 52, not the second appeals test. Both rejected the Respondent’s attempt to create an elevated threshold test for the grant of permission to appeal. As the Court of Appeal held § para 77:
“the test for an appeal to the Court of Appeal from the UT in cases of this kind, which are claims for judicial review heard by the UT exercising its original jurisdiction rather than appeals from the FTT, is the first appeal test and not the second appeal test. The UT erred in applying the second appeal test”.
Applying the first appeals test, the Court of Appeal dismissed the application for permission to appeal the costs order on the basis that the costs decision of the Upper Tribunal was correctly made. However, the Court of Appeal certified that the decision may be cited in other cases in satisfaction of para 6.1 of the Practice Direction (Citation of Authorities).
Arfan Khan appeared for the First Applicant whose submissions were successful on the point of principle, which led the Respondent to concede the same in a skeleton and at the oral hearing following the service of Replacement Grounds of Appeal on behalf of the First Applicant. Arfan Khan also successfully resisted the Respondent’s application for costs. The Court of Appeal did not make any costs orders.
Arfan Khan was instructed by Dylan Konrad Kreolle Solicitors on appeal to the Court of Appeal, and did not appear in the proceedings below. The Court of Appeal judgment can be accessed through the following links:
A 42BR Employment Webinar, presented by Jason Braier and Jamie Fireman. Read more >
Paul Fuller, a member of our Business & Property Group, summarises and considers the case ClientEarth v Shell plc & Ors  Read more >