Housing Bulletin No 15 – Some Top Tips for Tenancy Fraud Cases
Welcome to this, the fifteenth bulletin from the Housing Team.
We hope that you will find the content of interest: if you wish to receive further updates you can subscribe by replying to firstname.lastname@example.org
Some Top Tips for Tenancy Fraud Cases
Six years ago, the National Fraud Authority launched its Social Housing Tenancy Fraud Project that aimed to encourage Local Authorities and Registered Providers to tackle tenancy fraud more aggressively. In October 2013, the Prevention of Social Housing Fraud Act came into force and saw tenancy fraud become an express criminal offence. Today, demand for social housing continues to outstrip supply. Peter Jolley asks what else can be done to win the fight against tenancy fraud.
One: Prevention is Better than Cure
Stopping fraud in the first place is likely to much more cost – effective in the long term. As social housing landlords will know, it can be very difficult and expensive process to regain possession or take other legal action against an employee or supplier tied up in a fraud. Fraud in any event extends beyond financial loss; it can undermine an organisation’s reputation and that organisation’s ability to maintain homes and build new properties.
Two: Use the Internet
The internet is an essential tool when it comes to prevention. Tenants regularly publish astonishing amounts of personal information on the web. Use online passport checking services when establishing identity. If a prospective tenant cannot provide utility statements, ask them to print them from online. If you later suspect fraud, then look at sites such as Facebook and Gumtree. Set up anonymous accounts to do so. If a tenant has a ‘locked down’ profile, look at their friend’s’ profiles instead. You may find some helpful post concerning the tenant’s true whereabouts and accompanying photographs can prove excellent evidence.
Three: Tenancy Agreements
Before you let a tenant into a property, tighten up your tenancy agreements. Remember that the more serious offence under the Prevention of Social House Fraud Act 2013 (which may go to the Crown Court_ requires a tenant to act dishonestly, in breach of tenancy, when subletting without consent and ceasing to occupy the property as their only or principal home. Use the words from the Act, including ‘dishonestly’, when drafting clauses. Include a statement that a tenant may lose their home if they make misrepresentations. Require contact details if a tenant is away for more than 28 days. Include a clause that the tenant is representing that they are living at the property every time they pay rent.
Four: Audits are Not Enough
Tenancy audits will often not be sufficient to tackle fraud. It is hardly difficult for a fraudulent tenant to arrange to be at a property if an inspection is announced in advance. Procedures that include unannounced tenancy checks may involve more resources should a legitimate tenant not be at home on a first visit, but persistent absence may provide essential evidence when trying to regain possession.
Five: Ask the Neighbours
Neighbours may understandably be reluctant to assist in fraud investigations. Consider providing systems such as dedicated phone lines or web reporting pages for those who are concerned. Reassure people that it is entirely legitimate to raise concerns in this way. Promote these systems in your regular engagements with your tenants. This may in itself cause potential fraudsters to think again.
Six: Show your Hand
Most tenants will surrender their tenancy at the point of detection or when they received notice that a claim has been issued. This is more likely to happen if you have a strong, well put together pack of evidence. Screenshots from a tenant’s own social media account can be particularly effective in this respect. Spending more time on investigation may therefore save costs in the long run. If you do intend to issue, serve a Notice of Seeking Possession with all grounds covered but without prejudice to a separate Notice to Quite (served on the basis that a tenant’s security has been lost).
Seven: Lost Income
Unlawful Profit Orders under the 2013 Act may be made retrospectively in civil courts. Online sites such as Gumtree may help when calculating average rents. Also bear in mind that the Proceeds of Crime Act 202 may be relevant when it comes to recovering money in more serious cases.
Eight: Share Best Practice
Share lessons learnt with other Councils and Housing Associations. Consider joining relevant networks. Remember that employees can also be involved in fraud and information sharing can help detect such instances.
This practice note has been written by Peter Jolley, a tenant at 42BR Barristers who regularly undertakes landlord and tenant work including the wide range of issues which relate to social housing.
Peter Jolley is a member of the 42BR Barristers Property Team, and specialises in all aspects of Housing Law.
42BR Barristers' Housing and Employment Groups are delighted to present the first two installments of our upcoming 'Introduction to Disability Discrimination Law for Housing Lawyers' events. Read more >
Join us in person or online for our latest Family Law event, exploring how digital forensics can impact family law proceedings. Read more >