Supreme Court Judgment re H-W

Following on from the Court of Appeal decision in re H-W, the Supreme Court have now decided on the appeal. At Supreme Court level, three members of Chambers appeared for the respondent Local Authority, Damian Woodward-Carlton QC, Sharan Bhachu and Katie Phillips, with Sharan Bhachu appearing at first instance and in the Court of Appeal. 

This is an important decision relating to the proportionality of making final care orders and reiterating the approach to be taken when children are being removed from their parents. The judgment also considers the role of the appellate court in such appeals. 

The judgments for both the Court of Appeal and Supreme Court can be found below:

Court of Appeal Judgment 

Supreme Court Judgment 

15th Jun 2022

Damian Woodward-Carlton KC

Call 1995 | Silk 2019

Katie Phillips KC

Call 2002 | Silk 2025

Sharan Bhachu

Call 1999